1. History
The classical approach to education puts history at the center of the curriculum spiral. While we don't follow the classical model of a four-year world history cycle done three times over the course of grades 1-12, I do agree with putting history at the center. History is the context and reason for pretty much every experience of modern living. The older I get the more I realize this is true. Solid historical education is essential to be a competent citizen of the world.
We use Sonlight for their history/literature curriculum, with a few modifications. I love their use of historical fiction for bringing history alive. There are several really good history books that we use as spines, which Sonlight also uses.
- Story of the World by Susan Wise Bauer. These four volumes covering all of world history are well written and engaging. There is an excellent activity guide for each book with more supplemental learning than we've ever been able to do. In grades 1-2 we use this as a read aloud while the kids do the coloring pages. In grades 6-7 our kids read them again, completing the tests that go along with them.
- History of US by Joy Hakim. This 10 volume set is so good that my husband read it along with the our daughters and sometimes would fight with them about time with the book. My 8th grade daughter, after reading the series and reviewing an AP prep book, took the U.S. History AP exam and got a 3. I just discovered that PBS has a companion site for the series.
- History of the World by Susan Wise Bauer. My older daughters used Sonlight through high school, but I'm so impressed with Bauer's high level history texts that I think we'll be using these when the next kids hit 10th grade.
2. Literature & Reading
In early grades we call it Reading. In later grades we call it Literature.
Teaching our children to read was one of the things that we had to go through several children before we felt like we've figured it out. We tried Learn to Read in 100 Easy Lessons, but only made it to about lesson 50 before the child melted down. We tried k12's reading program and it was OK but dealing with k12 was enough to make us re-evaluate educating at home. Finally, with our 6th child, I feel like we've found a curriculum that works well. We are using Primary Arts of Language and I'm really pleased with how easy it is to slow down or speed up and how enthusiastic my defiant little boy is about reading.
After they learn to read, everything changes. Sonlight has an excellent reading list that corresponds to the history study. From about grade 2 on, we use Sonlight's "Readers." In high school they include a good study guide with reflection questions. Sonlight asks for a lot of reading, but the novels they assign are so interesting that even my reticent readers stayed motivated to keep up.
We use Sonlight's literature right through high school and the difference in what my children experience and what the average student experiences is stark. My oldest attended a local high school that is considered the best in the state. He read 4-5 novels per year. My homeschooled children read 20+ novels per year. Not only does this expose them to much more great literature, it also builds up their reading endurance so that the very high volumes of reading that will be expected of them in college is not difficult.
3. Writing
I have written professionally for most of my adult life, but I could not figure out how to teach writing to my children. My poor oldest daughter had to endure lots of, "it's too wordy" or "it's too vague" with no direction how to actually address the problem. I had my children do lots of writing, but it seemed that instead of improving, they were just getting lots of practice writing badly.
Then we found Institute for Excellence in Writing. Their approach is quite simple and very concrete. I give the child a checklist of specific things to include in each paragraph and their papers are graded on whether or not they did those things. Period. No more ambiguous, subjective feed back from me. My children's frustration went down and their writing quality went way, way up.
4. Language Skills: Grammar, Usage, Vocabulary, Spelling
Language skills are necessary, but they are my least favorite part of homeschooling. Workbooks make it worse.
Spelling is a skill that I never personally learned in spelling class, so I tend to discount the value of teaching it. I learned to spell when I learned to type in junior high. But, OK, children do need to learn to spell. The problem is finding something that helps them learn to spell in their writing, not just on spelling tests. Weekly spelling lists didn't work. Sequential Spelling was OK for a while, but after we got up a few levels, it ceased being effective. Now we are using All About Spelling and having success with that. I like that it is multi-sensory, that it includes patterns, but also gives children rules to memorize.
Susan Wise Bauer has an elementary grammar program called First Language Lessons that is built on the classical model. I find it a little dry, but my sons like it. Institute for Excellence in Writing has a grammar program called Fix It and that my 8th grade twins like. My twins asked to do Vocabulary from Classical Roots, so I let them, but I never actively teach vocabulary. When children read lots, like mine do, they learn vocabulary naturally and effectively.
5. Math
Math is a subject that should be covered every day and every year, but how a child progresses will be up to them and their aptitude.
In the early years, you hardly need a curriculum because children are leaning the basics of counting, adding & subtracting and how to write it down. Different curriculums cover things in different orders so if you switch between curriculums, take a hard look at their placement tests to make sure you're moving into the right level.
I really like the approach of Singapore Math in elementary school. It's the national curriculum of the country of Singapore, whose students regularly score at the top of the world. Singapore moves from physical (manipulative), to concrete, to abstract even at the early stages. It leaves some concepts for the child to figure out, which has been shown to lead to the strongest learning. I really like Singapore Math for elementary grades, but we tried it in high school with my oldest and it was a complete fail.
We then had success with Teaching Textbooks beginning with Pre-Algebra. My children liked the approach and were generally successful, until my very math-competent daughter took Calculus and nearly failed. I've read that Teaching Textbooks isn't as comprehensive or delve as deeply into the material as they should and I wonder if that's the reason my daughter struggled with Calculus.
So now we've moved to Math U See. I like it as well, if not better, than Singapore Math for the younger kids and I'm finding that my 8th grade twins are learning Algebra deeper than my older daughter did with Teaching Textbooks. It has some content review but not too much, and moves kids into deeper understanding along the way.
6. Science
In the schools, science is barely touched in the elementary years. There is so much focus on reading, writing, and math that there is little time for much of anything else. But not for my kids!! They do science every day.
In the elementary years, I'm convinced there is no wrong way to do science, as long as the child is engaged and enthusiastic. You can read science books aloud; Usborne and DK have lots of great ones. You can do experiments & activities, Science Activities have lots of good ones. You can follow a curriculum so your activities reinforce academic content; Real Science 4 Kids have good ones.
And then children hit the junior high years and it's time to get serious. They need to learn the scientific method, lab skills, and comprehensive content, but so far I've not found a curriculum that I'm really pleased with. The curriculum that are pedagogically (oh, I love big words) good have weak content, and those with strong content are pedagogically taxing. When my older daughters went through high school we used Apologia, Singapore Science Matters, Kolbe science, NROC courses (which aren't around any more), and Christian Light Education. Of them all, Christian Light Education was the best for both solid content and good instructional approach, but the lay out is so boring. My twins are 8th grade and reading through the Story of Science by Joy Hakim right now, but I'm still searching for good high school science for them.
7. World Languages
When we are busy and/or stressed, we give up world languages, but I remain convinced that learning a second language is an important part of being a citizen of the world and a thinking human being.
There are several different software approaches to learning language. We've spent lots of money and haven't had great success. My children made it through Rosetta Stone's Spanish Level 3 and then complained that they were finding lots of errors. We've tried Learnables, but my kids said it was boring. We've used George Public Broadcasting's Salsa with younger kids. It was fun, they liked it, and they learned some. The only thing that seemed to be genuinely effective was Destinos, hosted by learner.org.
This year we are changing focus to Biblical Greek. I just love a language where you're not working up to conversation fluency.
8. Logic/Critical Thinking
In elementary years, the Critical Thinking Company has lots of good resources for learning logical thinking. The also have resources for things other than critical thinking, which don't impress me as much. In high school, the Analogies series is great for getting ready for SAT analogies.
In high school my older daughters did The Fallacy Detective. I thought it would be a good subject for them with such a high use of fallacies in our culture in advertising, politics, and now even news. But I had no idea how powerful it would be. Shortly after they finished it, the 2012 presidential election got into full swing. After watching a presidential debate, they spontaneously started naming all the fallacies they spotted. Yeah, I think that learning will serve them well their whole lives.
9. Art/Music
Before I had nine children, I had such a commitment to art and music, and now it often gets laid aside like world languages.
Artistic Pursuits has been wonderful for art history & instruction from Kindergarten all the way through high school. My kids learned how to look at art and how to incorporate new techniques into their own work.